Open vs. Closed Adoption in Wisconsin: Understanding Your Choices

Choosing adoption for your baby is a deeply personal decision, and understanding the differences between open and closed adoption can help you make the best choice for yourself and your child.

If you're considering adoption in Wisconsin, you have options that allow you to shape your adoption journey in a way that feels right for you.

 If you need immediate assistance, call 1-800-ADOPTION for 24/7 support, or request more information.

What is Open Adoption?

Open adoption is a process in which birth parents and adoptive families establish a relationship that allows for some level of ongoing contact and communication. This can take many forms, including direct visits, phone calls, video chats, and the exchange of letters and pictures through a mediator.

The level of openness varies based on individual preferences, and it can evolve over time to reflect the changing needs and comfort levels of both the birth parents and adoptive family.

In Wisconsin, open adoption agreements are widely practiced, offering birth mothers the reassurance of staying connected while allowing adoptive families the opportunity to foster a relationship that benefits the child.

This continued connection can provide birth mothers with emotional peace of mind, knowing their child is safe, loved, and thriving. It also gives adoptive families access to valuable medical and familial history that can help them provide better care for the child.

Because no two adoption journeys are the same, working with an adoption professional can help birth mothers create a plan that reflects their needs, preferences, and long-term comfort levels.

Levels of Openness

Open adoption can take different forms depending on the level of contact agreed upon between the birth parents and adoptive family:

• Fully Open Adoption – Direct contact and visits between the birth parents, child, and adoptive family.
• Semi-Open Adoption – Communication is limited to a few letters and pictures, often only a few times a year.
• Closed Adoption – No direct contact; this option has become less common over the years.

Pros of Open Adoption

Open adoption provides significant benefits for everyone involved, fostering healthier relationships and emotional security:

1. Benefits for the Birth Mother

Birth mothers in an open adoption can maintain a connection with their child and watch them grow, offering reassurance about their child’s well-being. This ongoing relationship also provides the opportunity to answer their child’s questions about their origins, helping to foster understanding and emotional security.

2. Benefits for the Adopted Child

From an early age, adopted children benefit from understanding their adoption story, which helps them develop a strong sense of identity and belonging.

Having access to medical history and background information provides valuable insights into their health and heritage, ensuring they feel connected to both their biological and adoptive families.

3. Benefits for the Adoptive Family

Adoptive families benefit from a deeper understanding of the child's background, which can foster a stronger connection and provide valuable context for parenting.

Support from the birth family can enhance the child's sense of belonging and identity, while transparency and open communication help ease the transition and create a more secure and loving environment for everyone involved.

4. Emotional and Psychological Benefits

Open adoption can help reduce feelings of loss and uncertainty by providing birth parents, adoptive families, and the child with ongoing connections and reassurance. It allows all parties to avoid lingering 'what if' scenarios by fostering clear communication and transparency.

This supportive adoption dynamic encourages emotional well-being, stability, and a positive relationship for everyone involved.

Cons of Open Adoption

Despite the many benefits, open adoption can present challenges that require careful consideration and clear boundaries:

1. Potential Challenges for the Birth Mother

Maintaining contact in an open adoption can present emotional challenges for birth mothers, as ongoing interaction may bring up complex feelings. Boundary issues can arise if expectations are not clearly defined, making it difficult to navigate relationships with the adoptive family.

Without clear agreements, moving forward can become emotionally complicated, highlighting the importance of setting expectations early in the process.

2. Challenges for the Adoptive Family

Conflicts over boundaries and communication can sometimes arise, leading to concerns about the birth mother’s level of involvement over time. Establishing clear agreements and expectations from the beginning can help create a healthy and positive relationship between all parties.

3. Challenges for the Adopted Child

Confusion about parental roles can arise if expectations are not clearly defined, leading to emotional complexities as the child navigates relationships with both birth and adoptive parents.

Ensuring open, age-appropriate communication helps create a supportive environment where the child can develop a healthy understanding of their unique family dynamic.

What is Closed Adoption?

In a closed adoption, there is no ongoing contact between the birth parents and the adoptive family, and identifying information remains confidential. All interactions and arrangements are facilitated through an adoption agency or legal representative, ensuring privacy and discretion throughout the process.

This option may appeal to birth mothers who seek a sense of finality and emotional distance, allowing them to move forward without the complexities of ongoing communication. While closed adoptions are less common today, they remain a viable option for those who prioritize privacy.

However, it is important to consider that a closed adoption may limit future access to medical history and personal background information, which could be significant for the child as they grow. It's also important to consider that your child may be able to find you eventually, due to the increased information online.

Choosing between open and closed adoption is a deeply personal decision, and birth mothers should take the time to evaluate which path best aligns with their emotional needs and long-term goals.

How to decide if Open Adoption is Right for You

Choosing between open and closed adoption is a personal decision based on your comfort with communication, emotional needs, and long-term vision. Open adoption allows for varying contact, while closed adoption offers finality with no direct involvement.

If maintaining a connection brings peace of mind, open adoption may be best. If closure is your priority, a closed adoption could provide the space you need. There is no wrong choice.

Get the Support You Deserve

Choosing adoption means making the best decision for you and your baby. You deserve support, guidance, and the ability to shape your adoption journey on your terms.

If you're unsure about your next steps, we’re here to provide the information and support you need. Call us today at 1-800-ADOPTION for immediate help.

Disclaimer
Information available through these links is the sole property of the companies and organizations listed therein. American Adoptions provides this information as a courtesy and is in no way responsible for its content or accuracy.